Key Legal Challenges For Startups In India And How To Overcome Them
Indian startups are innovations on the front lines, solving such crucial social, technological, and economic issues. Even though opportunities for startups have been tremendous, legal challenges have also stood out equally numerous. Navigating the Indian regulatory framework sometimes is intimidating, especially for a new business, which has little knowledge of the nuances of law. The article deals with major legal issues faced by Indian startups and provides suggestions as to how those issues could be overcome by referring to relevant statutes, ministry guidelines, case laws, and controls.
1. Incorporation and Business Structure
Business Structure Selection: Among the very first legal considerations that start-ups would face, business structures constitute an indispensable aspect of the overall business formation. Suitable business structures would include sole proprietorship, partnership, limited liability partnership, and private limited company. Each form of organization would be attached to different legal requirements, such as taxation, liability, and compliance.
Business incorporation is mainly governed by three statutes: Companies Act, 2013 for companies and Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008 regarding LLPs. Many options of structures are always available to start-ups, and the best possible structures often are not selected hence complications in compliance, liability, and taxation occur. For instance, when a business employs a sole proprietorship, unlimited liability may expose the business to potential danger in case it faces bankruptcy. This can be dealt with even before choosing the structure for the startup: business model, growth plans, and preferred liability setup. More than that, a detailed discussion with legal and financial advisors would help decide on the best structure. What’s more, there exists an e-portal by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs, which easily allows the registration of companies.
2. Regulatory Compliance
After incorporation of the company, quite a few legal and regulatory compliance issues arise which are to be complied with. Hence, a startup has to follow the following:
- Annual returns have to be filed with the Registrar of Companies (ROC)
- Labour laws have to be complied with which include the Minimum Wages Act, 1948
- Tax laws to be complied with which include (GST Act), Income Tax Act, and TDS provisions.
In the case of Tata Chemicals Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Gujarat, the court has clearly mentioned that the tax law needs to be followed and ignorance of law brings about punitive consequences. The appellant had argued that the Customs Authorities cannot be absolved from following the law based on the actions of a particular assessee, and claimed that something illegal cannot become legal by the act of a third person.
Startups usually face this problem of compliance since they usually are small in size and have the least resources and expertise. Leveraging legal technology tools and outsourcing the compliance functions to third-party service providers would move towards solving some of the issues. Now, there are third-party service providers who could be engaged to make this task less painful as the Startup India initiative has provided a compliance handbook specifically targeted towards startups.
3. Intellectual Property Rights (IPR)
Among the foremost and top priorities for any startup is the protection of innovation in the form of IP. IP is basically related to trademarks, patents, copyrights, and designs. However, attaining protection under IP requires an elongated and expensive process.
The IPR in India is mainly regulated by the Trade Marks Act, 1999, the Patents Act, 1970, and the Copyright Act, 1957. Patents are specifically significant in this regard. In cases like Bajaj Auto Ltd. v. TVS Motor Company Ltd, the courts have repeatedly pointed out that patent protection is of extreme importance to protect the technological novelty.
Generally, the start-ups miss IPR protection either due to cost factors or simple ignorance of doing it and thereby get victimized by infringement. Therefore, it is imperative for new startups to file patents, trademarks, or copyrights as early as the early stages of the new venture. There are multiple ways to attain legal assistance for the same. For instance, the Scheme for Facilitating Startups Intellectual Property Protection (SIPP) by the Indian Government offers legal aid with lesser cost factors. The National IPR Policy enhances more awareness of IP and speedy patent examination.
4. Fundraising and Investment Regulations
Capital formation is the most critical aspect for growth in any startup. However, Indian startups, regardless of foreign or domestic investments, face tough legal complexities to garner sums for their ventures. What makes it even more challenging is that the rule books related to securities laws, FDI policies, and private equity rules have to be known by them meticulously.
The law regarding the fundraising activities of capital markets is prescribed under the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992. Another set of norms is found under FEMA, 1999, which deals with the inflow of FDI into India. Repeated tussles emanating from the taxability of investments and income abroad land themselves in courts more often than not.
This generally happens due to a failure to respect the principles of FDI or those by SEBI invites penal sanctions, delayed funding, and even criminal liabilities. Most start-ups are also ignorant about the sectoral caps and sectoral restrictions. A start-up seeking foreign investment needs to consult lawyers about the policy of FDI and FEMA guidelines. RBI and SEBI have various circulars and guidelines for compliant investment practices. Platforms like Startup India also provide facilitation for investments by start-ups.
5. Data Protection and Privacy
The new generation of data-driven startups poses a challenge to further ensure that data protection and compliance will be enhanced. The legal architecture of India will undergo a change through the implementation of the new Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023. Apart from the said Act, data protection in India is governed under the Information Technology (IT) Act, 2000 as well.
Start-ups dealing with sensitive personal data are to abide by the stringent provisions of the DPDP Act, which inter alia provides for data localization and consent management in light of breach reporting. Especially as now the right to privacy has come as a fundamental right in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India, bringing about stringent governance over data protection.
Startups should be having very strong data protection policies and should be complying with the provisions under DPDP and IT Act. Data practices are to be regularly audited, and employees, who handle data, are to be trained in the same lines of data privacy practice. There are platforms like MeitY which issue guidelines and advisory on data protection practices.
6. Labour Laws and Employee Contracts
Employees bring many labour law compliances into the books. Employment laws applicable to such startups are the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, and Employee Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952.
It is difficult to understand the complex nature of labour laws while drafting employee contracts in compliance with all these; high penalties and litigation follow otherwise. Therefore, legal consultancy outreach to startups should prepare a balanced employment contract involving items on termination, restrictive covenants, confidentiality, and mechanism for a dispute resolution. Such registration under labour law frameworks would also entail complete compliance.
7. Contractual and Dispute Resolution Issues
Most of the startups sign agreements in the name of vendors, clients, or partners without any contractual documents. This often leads to disputes that involve a protracted and costly litigation process. The contractual obligations are covered by the Contract Act, 1872 and the disputes are resolved under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act of 1996.
Courts have highlighted arbitration mechanism as the mode to de-congest the judiciary time and again. Yet, the importance of a written contract and the arbitration clause during dispute resolution is often neglected. Thus, startups are prone to get caught in litigation or business disturbances. Thus, all their business deals need to be documented with well-worded contracts containing an arbitration or mediation clause for swift and inexpensive dispute resolution. Online arbitration websites can also help them resolve disputes speedily.
8. Taxation Issues
The Start-ups typically do not understand all the many tax benefits to which they are legally entitled, such as those offered by the Startup India scheme. Except for these, there are GST, income tax and more indirect taxes, which get pretty complicated. (Income Tax Act, 1961 and Goods and Services Tax (GST) Act deals with the tax liabilities of businesses.)
Non-filing of tax invites penalty and non-claiming of available exemptions adds further expenses on the business. If they consult tax experts, then all relief and exemption schemes will be beneficial for the startups to a significant level. Under this come schemes like Section 80-IAC of the Income Tax Act, which allows comprehensive tax holiday to all startup companies. Additionally, startups should also consider using automated accounting software which may be beneficial in serving GST and income-tax compliances.
Concluding Remarks
While being sizeable, the legal challenges for Indian startups are certainly not insurmountable. As long as there is awareness of the legal landscape and support from professionals, the issues could be systematically crossed over while concentrating on business growth. The friendly environment which the government’s initiative – Startup India – has furthered to them has done so even with laws like DPDP 2023. This is where awareness of compliance with regulatory changes, as well as strategic planning, will be the key to success for startups.
LEGALLANDS assist in services related to Drafting of Data Policies, Contract Conveyancing and Corporate Services, Business Set up and Management Services, Foreign Trade Policies, Immigration Services, Regulatory Compliances, Legal Compliances, Logistics Support, International Dispute Resolution, Trade Regulations, and many more. We also assist in logistics strategy analysis, risk assessment etc. Feel free to connect with us at connect@legallands.com. For further information visit our website on www.legallands.com.
